This goes to 1080p: Good/Better/Best options

HDTV is a fairly confusing morass of acronyms, standards, and buzzwords. Throw in the differences between plasma, LCD, and DLP and you’re left with an alphabet soup (this may help clear things up). What follows are three TVs you’ll want to check out when you decide to take the plunge and go for 1080p, the current cutting-edge for highest quality picture.

Good

I have a couple friends that own the Westinghouse LVM-42W2 42″ LCD. I like to think of it as the VW bug of 1080p: it’s cheap, it works well in most conditions, and while it’s not perfect it’s pretty damn good. Just a couple years ago, a LCD panel of this size would command a price above $5,000 and yet this highest definition panel runs around $1500 depending on where you shop. I know video games look amazing on it, HD-DVD looks pretty good, and regular ol’ HD channels are sharp. I hear the black levels leave something to be desired and there can be ghosting with high action, but overall you’re not going to get a bigger bang for the buck.

Better

Sony’s Bravia brand covers a wide-ranging line of LCD TVs and their latest KDL-46XBR3 is their top of the line 46 incher. It’s going to set you back about $3500 and it’s very sleek looking. Picture quality is superb on this unit. I’ve spent a couple hours watching one while shopping and if I had the spare cash to burn, this would be my choice. Color, brightness, and contrast are all so good I thought it was a plasma screen the first time I saw it (I can usually tell a plasma from a LCD). You do pay a little extra for the Sony name and in this specific model, a black bezel. It may sound silly, but the cheaper XBR2 model that comes in silver is identical but will save you about $300.

Best

Personally, I prefer the look of plasma over LCD because LCD sets often display a bit of pixels when the action gets intense (especially outlines of players during a football game). Part of the reason is simple physics: electricity moves through a gas (plasma) much faster than liquid (LCD) so pixels can change colors quicker on plasma.

The funny thing about plasma though is making a 1080p set is fairly difficult, requiring larger screens in order to fit so many pixels. If you ever read gadget blogs, you’ve often seen companies fighting for the crown of largest plasma screen, but Pioneer has gone the other way with 1080p plasma.

The Pro FHD1 is the world’s smallest plasma 1080p set, at 50″, and only because Pioneer did a lot of engineering to get the pixels so small. There’s an old cliche about HDTV, where everyone compares the technology to having “a picture that’s like looking out of a window” but if I had to describe the FHD1 demo set I saw in a high-end home theater store playing 1080p content, I would have to agree. Rich blacks, super high contrast, and bright colors. This set is as lifelike as it gets. When this TV came out in the spring, the list price was a cool $10,000, but now I see Pioneer listing it for $8k. At that price, only pro athletes and millionaire home theater fans may apply, but if you’re looking for the best of the best, the FHD1 is it.

10 Responses to “This goes to 1080p: Good/Better/Best options”

  1. David says:

    Why no mention of LCOS? For the money I was blown away by the 1080p sets compared to plasma. A noticeably better picture.

  2. Jemaleddin says:

    As another “good” option, the 37″ Sharp Aquos LCD is a real bargain.

  3. QueOnda says:

    I just bought a 73″ Mistubishi (model # 73831). I don’t know if my choice was poor.

  4. Matthew Haughey says:

    Why no mention of LCOS?

    I stuck with only flat TVs, like the kind that can be wall-mounted easily for this quick overview.

  5. Mike says:

    Which of these can actually take 1080p input? If they don’t support HDMI 1.3 like many of the first “1080p” TVs that were introduced… what’s the point?

  6. Matthew Haughey says:

    All three say they can handle 1080p on the HDMI input.

  7. Raymond Day says:

    There are a lot of 720 so called HD TV’s out there. But if people get them they will be sorry. You have to get the 1080p ones. That’s 1920 by 1080. Most computer monitors can’t do that. I guess in 1 or 2 years you will see no 720 type HD TV’s.

    -Raymond Day

  8. Raymond Day says:

    On a HD TV if it’s not the full 1920 by 1080 the tuner has to resize it and if the tuner is not fast then fast move ment on the screen will get bigger and bigger blocks as the screen moves faster and faster the bigger the blocks get. Don’t get a so called 1280 by 720 or 1368 by 768 HD TV! HD TV is 1920 by 1080! They should not call the none 1080p HD TV’s.

    -Raymond Day

  9. My Gadget Info » Blog Archive » This goes to 1080p: Good/Better/Best options says:

    […] Over on the Holiday Gadget Guide, I posted a quick review of three 1080p flat TV options. I haven’t gone 1080p yet, but when the Playstation 3 and high definition DVDs are easily available, it’ll be time to take the plunge. […]

  10. Stargazer says:

    Lost in all the new tvs are continuation of providing two ntsc tuners that allow you to implement PIP on the stardand channels. No set top boxes allow PIP. The ability to do PIP on the RF input is still a top feature with me. Anyone know a set that still has two ntsc tuners?

Comments have been closed for this site.